Square Loyalty Program Review (2026): Pricing & Alternatives

Square Loyalty does the job — if you're happy paying $45 a month per location for a points program. For a single café or salon, that's $540 a year before you've sent a single marketing campaign. This review covers what Square Loyalty does well, where it falls short, and how to run a deeper loyalty program on your Square register for less.

#What is Square Loyalty and how does it work?

Square Loyalty is the loyalty add-on built into Square POS. Customers earn points on purchases — per visit, per dollar spent, or on specific items. You pick the reward, and Square tracks everything at the register.

It's a genuinely well-integrated product. Customers enroll at checkout with their phone number. Points get added when staff process the sale. Bigger spenders can unlock VIP tiers — Bronze, Silver, Gold. Customers get automatic texts about their points, and they can keep a digital pass in Apple Wallet.

If your whole business runs through Square, it works smoothly. The question is the price — and what you actually get for it.

#How much does Square Loyalty cost?

$45 a month per location, after a 30-day free trial. Two locations: $90 a month. Three: $135. There's no volume discount — the fee just multiplies.

That's the loyalty subscription alone. Marketing campaigns — the emails and texts that actually bring people back — are a separate Square Marketing subscription. Card processing fees still apply to every sale, reward redemptions included. And Square has started folding Loyalty into its paid Plus bundle, which means the cheapest path to loyalty may be a bigger subscription than you wanted.

For a single café, $540 a year is real money. That's a lot of free coffees you could have given away instead.

#Is Square Loyalty worth it?

It depends on what you're running.

It's worth it if you have several busy locations, you want everything inside one Square account, and a points-and-tiers program fits how your customers buy. The integration is seamless, and for a high-volume operation the fee disappears into the noise.

It's probably not worth it if you run one or two locations on thin margins. 73% of small businesses still have no loyalty program — not because loyalty doesn't work, but because the tools cost too much. We've written before about whether a loyalty program is worth it for a small cafe — the answer is yes, even with 50 regulars. The real question is what you pay to run one.

There's also the mechanics. Square Loyalty is built around points. But for most counters, a simple stamp card beats points — no mental math, no "how much is 120 points?" at the register. Costa Coffee famously switched from points to stamps and saw 16% more transactions. If you want a stamp card, memberships, coupons, or prepaid bundles, you're outside what Square Loyalty does.

#Can you run a loyalty program on Square without paying for Square Loyalty?

Yes. Loyalty platforms can connect to your Square account and earn from your register sales — no Square Loyalty subscription needed. Passtastic's Square integration works on plain Square:

1. 1Connect your Square account once. A secure connection through Square — you can disconnect anytime.
2. 2Your staff tap "Add customer" at checkout. That's the whole earning flow. The sale adds stamps or points to the customer's card automatically — no extra scanner, no second device.
3. 3When a reward is ready, scan once. Your staff scan the customer's pass with the free scanner app to confirm it's genuine — that stops reused screenshots — then apply the discount in Square like any other.

You choose how a sale earns: one stamp per paid visit, or stamps and points by amount spent. The reward is created as a discount in your Square automatically.

And the card itself does more. Stamp cards, points, levels, memberships, coupons, prepaid — you pick the mechanic that fits your counter. The card lands in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, with a printable PDF for customers who want neither. Push notifications are included — "you're 2 stamps away from a free coffee" lands right on their lock screen, and three out of four of those actually get read.

It's built for the counters Square is built for — see how loyalty for coffee shops works in practice. And Square sits alongside the rest of the tools Passtastic connects to — your website, Zapier, your email list. Setup takes about five minutes: create your loyalty card, publish it, and connect Square from your dashboard.

#Square Loyalty vs Passtastic: side by side

If you want one vendor for everything and points fit your business, Square Loyalty is the tidy choice. If you want loyalty that costs less, offers more card types, and stays yours no matter what register you use — that's what we built.

“

I usually check four or five companies. I think your product was the most straightforward.

“

Ofek, Owner of Tune In & Figa Garden

Read their story →